Pizza is a beloved staple in the American diet, but not all pies are created equal. With so many popular pizza chains vying for your business, it can be tough to separate the wheat from the chaff. We’ve done the legwork for you, ranking 10 well-known pizza chains from worst to best. Prepare to be surprised by which big-name brands are serving up disappointing dishes and discover which chain truly delivers the best bang for your buck.
1. Chuck E. Cheese
Languishing at the bottom of our list is Chuck E. Cheese, a chain better known for its arcade games than its subpar pizza. Customers complain of unappetizing cheese, low-quality toppings, and a crust that resembles cardboard. The high prices and poor service only add insult to injury.
If you’re looking for a satisfying slice, steer clear of this establishment. The only thing worse than the food is the creepy animatronic band that serenades you while you eat. Save your money and your taste buds by opting for a higher-quality pizza joint.
Fun fact: Chuck E. Cheese has racked up over 170 negative reviews for its lackluster pizza and shoddy service. It’s no wonder this chain is at the bottom of the barrel when it comes to customer satisfaction.
2. Little Caesars
Next up is Little Caesars, known for its budget-friendly $5 pizzas. While the price may be right, the quality leaves much to be desired. Critics slam the chain for its low-grade ingredients and lack of flavor.
Sure, you may be tempted by the prospect of a cheap meal, but is it really worth sacrificing taste for savings? With its cracker-thin crust and artificial butter flavor, Little Caesars’ pizza is a far cry from the real deal.
If you’re in a pinch and need a quick bite, Little Caesars may suffice. But if you’re looking for a truly satisfying pizza experience, you’re better off spending a few extra bucks elsewhere.
3. Papa John’s
Papa John’s may tout “better ingredients, better pizza,” but many customers beg to differ. Reviews suggest that the chain doesn’t live up to its slogan, with pizzas that are “lacking” in flavor and quality.
The crust is often described as overly thick and doughy, with a chemical aftertaste that lingers long after the meal is over. The cheese is also a point of contention, with many diners commenting on its poor texture and flavor.
While Papa John’s garlic dipping sauce is a fan favorite, it’s not enough to save the subpar pizza. If you’re looking for a pie that truly delivers on taste and quality, you may want to pass on this popular chain.
4. Pizza Hut
Once a dominant force in the pizza world, Pizza Hut has fallen from grace in recent years. Critics cite the chain’s overly sweet dough and sauce as major drawbacks, detracting from the overall flavor of the pizza.
While Pizza Hut’s cheese is a highlight, with good flavor and texture, it’s not enough to compensate for the cloying crust and saccharine sauce. The chain’s recent menu changes, including the addition of a Detroit-style pizza, have been met with mixed reviews.
If you have a sweet tooth, Pizza Hut may be right up your alley. But if you prefer a more traditional, savory pizza, you may want to look elsewhere.
5. Domino’s
Domino’s has undergone a major rebranding in recent years, with a focus on improving the quality of its ingredients and recipes. While some customers appreciate the chain’s efforts, others argue that the quality still varies widely from location to location.
On the plus side, Domino’s garlic-dusted crust and robust tomato sauce are definite high points. The cheese is also a standout, with just the right amount of stretch and flavor.
However, some customers complain of inconsistency, with certain locations using lower-quality toppings or skimping on ingredients altogether. If you’re willing to take a gamble, Domino’s may be worth a try, but be prepared for a potentially hit-or-miss experience.
6. Papa Murphy’s
Papa Murphy’s unique take-and-bake model sets it apart from other pizza chains, but opinions are divided on whether this format actually produces a superior product. Some reviewers praise the freshness of the ingredients, while others criticize the chain for its inferior quality and poor crust texture.
One major selling point of Papa Murphy’s is the ability to customize your pizza with a wide array of toppings. However, some customers argue that the toppings are no better than what you’d find at a lower-end chain.
7. Mellow Mushroom
Mellow Mushroom is a relative newcomer to the pizza scene, but it’s quickly making a name for itself with its creative flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients. From its signature psychedelic decor to its eclectic menu, this chain is all about standing out from the crowd.
While some purists may balk at Mellow Mushroom’s unconventional toppings (think avocado, pineapple, and jalapeños), adventurous eaters will appreciate the chain’s willingness to push the boundaries of traditional pizza. The crust is also a highlight, with a crispy exterior and chewy interior that’s sure to satisfy.
Whether you’re a pizza traditionalist or a flavor trailblazer, Mellow Mushroom is definitely worth checking out. With its commitment to quality ingredients and inventive recipes, this chain is quickly becoming a fan favorite.
8. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza is another up-and-coming chain that’s shaking up the fast-casual pizza scene. With its customizable pies and commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients, MOD is a great option for diners who want a personalized pizza experience.
One of the biggest selling points of MOD is its unlimited toppings policy. Customers can load up their pies with as many ingredients as they like, all for one flat price. This approach encourages experimentation and allows diners to create their perfect pizza.
While some may argue that the crust at MOD is on the thinner side, the chain makes up for it with its generous portions and top-notch toppings. If you’re looking for a pizza that’s tailored to your exact tastes, MOD is definitely worth a visit.
9. Jet’s Pizza
Jet’s Pizza is a Midwest favorite that’s slowly but surely making its way across the country. Known for its deep-dish Detroit-style pies, Jet’s is a great option for those who like their pizza thick and hearty.
While some may find Jet’s pizzas a bit too greasy, fans of the chain appreciate the crispy, caramelized crust and generous amounts of cheese and toppings. The chain’s signature Turbo Crust, which is brushed with garlic and butter, is also a major draw.
If you’re in the mood for a serious pizza feast, Jet’s is definitely worth checking out. Just be prepared to loosen your belt a notch or two.
10. California Pizza Kitchen
Taking the top spot on our list is California Pizza Kitchen, a chain that’s synonymous with gourmet pizza. With its wood-fired ovens, premium toppings, and inventive flavor combinations, CPK is the go-to choice for diners who want a truly elevated pizza experience.
From its legendary BBQ Chicken Pizza to its Thai Chicken Pie, CPK offers a wide range of globally inspired creations that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. The chain’s attention to detail is evident in every bite, from the perfectly crispy crust to the fresh, high-quality ingredients.
While CPK may be a bit pricier than some of its competitors, the extra cost is well worth it for the exceptional quality and flavor. If you’re looking for a pizza that’s a cut above the rest, California Pizza Kitchen is the clear winner.
When it comes to pizza chains, there’s no shortage of options to choose from. But as our ranking demonstrates, not all pies are created equal. By steering clear of the bottom-dwellers and opting for the cream of the crop, you can ensure that every pizza night is a delicious success. Just remember: when in doubt, always trust your taste buds. After all, pizza is a highly personal matter.
