9 Peanut Butter Brands Ranked Worst To Best

From The Blog

Peanut butter is an iconic, versatile spread, loved by millions for its rich, creamy texture and nutritious profile. A classic American staple, peanut butter is the protagonist of myriad recipes, from sandwiches to gourmet desserts, each delivering a unique symphony of flavors.

However, with a plethora of brands flooding the market, identifying the quintessential peanut butter becomes a delectable journey of culinary exploration. Let’s delve deeper into the nuanced world of peanut butter, ranking the varieties from the least favored to the absolute best, based on expert reviews and taste tests.

1. Great Value and Peter Pan

Great Value and Peter Pan are usually recognized for their budget-friendly options, but they have often received mixed reviews from consumers and experts alike. Despite their affordability, they have been critiqued for having a somewhat off-putting taste or texture that doesn’t quite meet the standard of more premium brands.

While some users find them acceptable, particularly those who prioritize cost over taste, others find them lacking in flavor richness and creamy consistency. A Mashed.com article concurs, suggesting they might not be the best options for a discerning palate seeking a gourmet experience. However, for those who desire a basic, straightforward peanut butter experience, these brands might still be worth considering.

2. Once Again and Smucker’s Natural

Once Again and Smucker’s Natural promise the allure of natural ingredients, but they have been reported to miss the mark on taste and texture. Some consumers found them to be too bland or to possess a burnt taste with oils that tend to separate. The natural approach might appeal to those seeking a less processed option, but it seems to come with a compromise on the overall eating experience.

The lack of emulsifiers leads to oil separation and requires stirring, which might not appeal to everyone. A taste test highlighted these aspects, suggesting there are better alternatives available for those prioritizing flavor and convenience alongside natural ingredients.

3. Whole Foods 365

Whole Foods 365, although synonymous with organic and high-quality products, surprisingly finds its peanut butter lacking according to several reviews. Critics mention its natural separation and plain flavor as major drawbacks, coupled with a price tag that is higher compared to other brands.

Consumers searching for rich, robust flavors might find this brand a bit underwhelming. The texture, due to the lack of hydrogenated oils, can be a bit off-putting for some, and it requires mixing before use. For a premium brand associated with quality, Whole Foods 365 didn’t seem to live up to the expectations in various analyses, especially considering the premium price point.

4. Trader Joe’s

Trader Joe’s is celebrated for its range of unique and high-quality products, and its peanut butter is no exception. It boasts natural ingredients and has won favor for its health-conscious formulation. However, some users have given mixed reviews regarding its texture, which can be a bit chunky due to the absence of hydrogenated oils. This leads to a texture that some find less pleasing compared to creamier alternatives.

While the natural, uncompromised taste has its admirers, others long for a smoother, creamier consistency. As highlighted in reviews, it’s a balanced option for those who prefer a more natural and textured peanut butter experience but might not satisfy fans of ultra-creamy varieties.

5. Skippy

Skippy, a classic in the peanut butter world, is revered by many for its smooth texture and balanced taste. However, it has also seen its share of critics, with some consumers divided over its taste and slightly pasty texture. For lovers of a creamy, traditional peanut butter, Skippy often hits the spot, but those seeking a more robust, intense peanut flavor might find it lacking.

Some argue that the texture, although smooth, has a stickiness that’s less than desirable. Various reviews suggest that while it’s a reliable choice for many households, the brand has room to enhance its flavor profile and texture to meet the evolving palate of today’s consumers.

6. MaraNatha

MaraNatha is a brand that finds a harmonious middle ground in the peanut butter spectrum. Whether consumers prefer creamy or crunchy, MaraNatha seems to deliver a pleasing consistency that appeals to a broad audience. However, it has faced comments about being somewhat too sweet for some palates.

While the sweetness levels may elevate the flavor for some, others may find it overshadows the natural, nutty richness of the peanuts. The brand has received positive feedback for its texture, but the sweetness level has been a point of contention in numerous reviews, making it a matter of personal preference.

7. Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter

Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter has garnered acclaim for its simple, clean ingredients and impressive texture. It strikes an exquisite balance in flavor, ensuring a delightful peanut butter experience. The brand has been a favorite among those who appreciate a more natural, uncompromised taste with a texture that’s neither too creamy nor too chunky.

It receives high marks for its ability to deliver a satisfying experience without unnecessary additives or excessive sweetness, marking it as a top-tier option for peanut butter connoisseurs. Numerous critics laud Justin’s for maintaining quality and taste, making it a standout choice in the peanut butter aisle.

8. Adam’s 100% Natural Peanut Butter

Adam’s 100% Natural Peanut Butter stands out for its commitment to purity and natural flavor. The brand avoids additives, focusing on delivering the unadulterated taste of peanuts. It has been praised for its creamy consistency and straightforward flavor profile that doesn’t compromise on taste.

While the natural formulation means the oil separates and requires stirring before use, many consider it a small inconvenience for enjoying the pure, rich taste of peanuts. Several rankings have positioned it as a top pick for those who prefer their peanut butter free of extras and full of natural goodness.

9. Spread The Love

Spread The Love has rightly earned its place at the zenith of the peanut butter hierarchy. This brand, with its minimal ingredients and uncompromised flavor, ensures that consumers experience peanuts in their purest form.

It’s often the preferred choice for those who seek a smooth, velvety texture combined with an authentic peanut taste, without any unnecessary additives. It has consistently emerged as a favorite in various evaluations for its dedication to quality and flavor, securing its position as one of the best peanut butters available on the market.

In conclusion, the journey to finding your perfect peanut butter is laden with diverse textures, flavors, and compositions. While the above rankings shed light on the various offerings in the market, personal preference plays a crucial role in determining the right fit.

Whether it’s the creamy classic or the natural contender, there’s a jar out there ready to spread joy and tantalize your taste buds. So, venture forth and explore the multifaceted world of peanut butter to find your ideal match!

Note: The ranking above is based on aggregated reviews and may not reflect the opinions of all consumers.

Jamie Anderson
Jamie Anderson
Hey there! I'm Jamie Anderson. Born and raised in the heart of New York City, I've always had this crazy love for food and the stories behind it. I like to share everything from those "Aha!" cooking moments to deeper dives into what's really happening in the food world. Whether you're here for a trip down culinary memory lane, some kitchen hacks, or just curious about your favorite eateries, I hope you find something delightful!

Latest Articles

More Articles Like This