When the leaves start to turn and the air gets crisp, pumpkin pie becomes the dessert of the season. There’s something magical about the combination of sweet pumpkin, warm spices, and flaky crust that makes us all weak in the knees. But with so many options available on the market, how does one choose the best store-bought pumpkin pie? Fear not, dear reader, for we have scoured the shelves, perused customer reviews, and even indulged in a taste test or two, all in the name of finding the top 7 pumpkin pies you can buy today.
1. Costco’s Famous Pumpkin Pie
The undeniable king of store-bought pumpkin pies, Costco’s pumpkin pie, takes the crown with its unbeatable combination of quality, affordability, and sheer size. Weighing in at a whopping 3.8 pounds and with a diameter of 12 inches, this pie is a feast fit for a king, or at least a very hungry family. According to sources, it’s not just the size that impresses; the taste is out of this world too, with a perfect balance of pumpkin and spices, all nestled in a flaky, buttery crust. It’s no wonder that Costco’s pumpkin pie has developed a cult following over the years.
Costco’s pumpkin pie is also lauded for its accessibility and popularity among customers, ensuring that you can find this delightful treat at a Costco near you during the holiday season. And the best part? The price. At under $10, this pie delivers exceptional value for money, making it the go-to choice for families looking to indulge without breaking the bank. So, if you’re on the hunt for a pumpkin pie that ticks all the boxes, look no further than Costco’s famous pumpkin pie.
2. Wegmans Pumpkin Pie
Coming in at a close second, Wegmans pumpkin pie is a force to be reckoned with in the world of store-bought desserts. Described as having a “flaky crust and creamy filling,” this pie is the epitome of homemade goodness. Reviewers rave about its perfect balance of cinnamon and pumpkin flavors, creating a harmonious blend that dances on the taste buds. The pie’s aesthetic appeal is also noteworthy, making it a show-stopping centerpiece for any holiday spread.
While Wegmans pumpkin pie may not have the size or the low price point of Costco’s version, it more than makes up for it in quality and taste. Customers are consistently impressed with the pie’s homemade feel, often mistaking it for a recipe handed down through generations. For those seeking a gourmet option without the gourmet price tag, Wegmans pumpkin pie is the way to go.
3. Trader Joe’s Pumpkin Pie
Trader Joe’s has a well-deserved reputation for delivering high-quality products at affordable prices, and their pumpkin pie is no exception. Weighing in at just over 24 ounces, this pie offers a perfect blend of spice and sweetness, capturing the essence of autumn in every bite. Customers love the rich, velvety texture of the filling, as well as the buttery crunch of the crust. The pie is also noted for its ideal size, making it a great option for smaller gatherings or those looking to enjoy a delicious treat without the commitment of a larger pie.
Another major plus for Trader Joe’s pumpkin pie is its price. At under $7, this pie offers exceptional value, ensuring that you can enjoy a top-notch dessert without stretching your budget. So, for those in search of a delicious, affordable, and perfectly sized pumpkin pie, Trader Joe’s has you covered.
4. Marie Callender’s Pumpkin Pie
Marie Callender’s is a name synonymous with delicious, homestyle pies, and their pumpkin pie is no exception. Boasting a “rich and smooth” filling and a “flaky, buttery crust,” this pie delivers on all fronts. Taste testers rave about its depth of flavor, noting that the spices are perfectly balanced and not overpowering. The pie’s texture is also a point of praise, with a creamy consistency that melts in your mouth.
While Marie Callender’s pumpkin pie may be on the pricier side compared to other options on this list, many believe that the quality justifies the cost. This pie is a hit among customers looking for a nostalgic, comforting dessert that tastes just like grandma used to make. So, if you’re willing to spend a bit more for a premium pumpkin pie experience, Marie Callender’s is the way to go.
5. Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pumpkin Pie
Sara Lee is a household name when it comes to desserts, and their Oven Fresh Pumpkin Pie is a testament to their reputation for quality. Described as having a “smooth and spicy” filling and a “tender crust,” this pie is a delightful addition to any holiday table. Customers appreciate the pie’s consistency, noting that it’s neither too sweet nor too spicy, striking a perfect balance. The crust is also a point of praise, with its flaky texture and buttery flavor.
The Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pumpkin Pie is reasonably priced, making it an attractive option for those looking to enjoy a delicious dessert without overspending. So, for a pumpkin pie that delivers on taste, texture, and value, Sara Lee is a solid choice.
6. Whole Foods Market Pumpkin Pie
Whole Foods Market is known for its commitment to quality and organic ingredients, and their pumpkin pie lives up to these standards. With a “rich and creamy” filling and a “sturdy crust,” this pie offers a gourmet twist on the classic dessert. The pie’s flavor profile is robust, with a noticeable pumpkin presence and a harmonious blend of spices. The crust is also noteworthy, providing a solid foundation for the decadent filling.
While Whole Foods Market’s pumpkin pie is pricier than some of the other options on this list, customers are willing to pay a premium for the assurance of organic ingredients and top-notch quality. So, for those looking for a luxurious pumpkin pie experience, Whole Foods Market is the place to go.
7. Pillsbury Frozen Pumpkin Pie
Pillsbury is a brand that has been delighting families for generations, and their Frozen Pumpkin Pie is a convenient and delicious option for the holiday season. With a “smooth and flavorful” filling and a “flaky crust,” this pie offers a delightful taste experience. Customers appreciate the ease of preparation, with the frozen pie baking up perfectly in the oven. The flavor is well-balanced, with just the right amount of spice to complement the pumpkin.
Additionally, Pillsbury’s Frozen Pumpkin Pie is budget-friendly, providing a cost-effective option for those looking to enjoy a tasty dessert without spending a fortune. So, for a convenient, delicious, and affordable pumpkin pie, Pillsbury is a top contender.
In conclusion, the world of store-bought pumpkin pies is vast and varied, with options to suit every taste and budget. Whether you’re looking for a gigantic feast, a gourmet treat, or a convenient and affordable option, there’s a pumpkin pie on this list for you. So, go ahead, indulge in the season’s favorite dessert, and let the flavors of autumn delight your taste buds!
